Managed care plans are a staple in the optometric industry, offering patients access to vision benefits that often include “zero dollar” lens options—lenses that incur no out-of-pocket costs for patients. While these plans increase patient engagement and foot traffic, they also pose a unique profitability challenge. Practices need to find a balance between fulfilling insurance obligations and encouraging patients to invest in higher-value lens products.
Profitability in managed care lens sales depends on effectively presenting premium lens options and communicating their value to patients. By using key strategies—emphasizing savings, training staff to lead with premium choices, and consistently tracking key metrics—your practice can thrive, even within the constraints of managed care plans.
Why Track Average Lens Price?
One of the most important metrics in managing lens sales under managed care is the Average Patient Price for Lens Sales, which measures the average amount patients spend out of pocket on lenses. This metric provides insight into how successfully your team is communicating the value of premium lens upgrades beyond the basic “zero dollar” options. Monitoring this figure allows practices to assess how well they are positioning premium products and how frequently patients are opting for upgrades.
A higher Average Patient Price indicates that patients recognize the value of premium lenses and are willing to make an out-of-pocket investment in better quality.
Effectively Selling Managed Care Lenses
Selling managed care lenses profitably hinges on your team’s ability to communicate the benefits of premium lenses over the “zero dollar” options. This involves educating patients on how their insurance provides valuable discounts and training staff to present higher-value choices strategically. Tracking the Average Patient Price for Lenses helps ensure your approach is effective and provides a data-driven way to make adjustments as needed.
Focusing too much on the free options offered by managed care can lead patients to assume that premium lenses are unnecessary. Instead, it’s important to position premium lenses as the preferred option, highlighting their long-term benefits and superior quality.
Real-World Discussion
A common challenge with managed care is the tendency to lead with “zero dollar” lens options. These plans often require you to offer these basic lenses, but if presented first, patients may assume this is the only or best option available. Your team should lead with premium lens options.
For example, if a patient’s plan covers basic lenses but allows for an upgrade to premium lenses at a reduced cost, the staff should emphasize the benefits of the upgrade—superior materials, comfort, and durability. Framing the conversation around how much the patient saves with their insurance, rather than how much the upgrade costs, increases the likelihood that the patient will choose the premium option.
If a practice sells 100 pairs of lenses to managed care patients in a month and previously saw only 20% opting for premium upgrades – using their insurance benefits to discount their lens purchase, as opposed to getting “just what’s covered,” shifting to lead with these options could easily double that rate to 40%. With an average out-of-pocket spend of $95, this shift would yield an additional $1,900 in revenue.
In another scenario, a practice found its Average Patient Price lower than expected for managed care patients under a specific plan. Upon reviewing staff conversations, they realized employees were too quick to offer the fully-covered, “zero dollar” option. After retraining the team to lead with premium lenses and demonstrate long-term savings, the Average Patient Price increased by 25% for patients participating in this plan, translating to an additional $1,850 in monthly revenue from this patient group.
Sales Training: Change the Language
Success in selling premium lenses under managed care plans starts with comprehensive staff training. Your team needs to be well-versed in both the features of the premium lenses and the specific insurance benefits patients can use to upgrade. Role-playing exercises, where staff practice conversations with patients, can be a helpful tool in building confidence and consistency in messaging.
It’s crucial to train your staff to lead the conversation with the value of premium lenses, rather than defaulting to the free options. For example, staff should be trained to say, “With your insurance, you can save on these premium lenses that offer more durability and comfort,” instead of, “Your insurance covers these lenses for free.” This shift in focus can encourage patients to invest in higher-quality products.
Additionally, consider inviting your lab or lens company representatives to provide training on effectively communicating the benefits of premium lenses. These resources are generally free, and representatives are usually eager to help.
Overcoming Common Challenges
One of the biggest challenges in selling premium lenses to managed care patients is overcoming the perception that “free” is good enough. Patients who see “zero dollar” lens options covered by their insurance may be reluctant to explore upgrades unless the benefits are clear.
To counter this, practices must focus on demonstrating the value of premium lenses—not just in terms of visual performance but also in comfort, durability, and long-term savings. Staff should use examples such as, “These lenses will last you longer and provide more comfort throughout the day,” to make the case for upgrading.
Ensuring that staff remain consistent in their messaging is vital. Regularly reviewing conversations between staff and patients, as well as tracking metrics like Average Patient Price, will help identify areas where staff may need additional training or support.
Managing the Metric
The Average Patient Price for Lens Sales should be tracked regularly—at least monthly, if not more frequently. Managing this metric through analytics software or manual tracking allows practices to monitor how often patients upgrade to premium lenses and adjust their approach accordingly.
Patient Price Lens Sales
| Week | Plan A | Plan B | Plan C | Private Pay | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total Pairs | $0 Pairs | Ave Price | Total Pairs | $0 Pairs | Ave Price | Total Pairs | $0 Pairs | Ave Price | Total Pairs | $0 Pairs | Ave Price | |
| 3/16/24 | 13 | 3 | $95 | 7 | 1 | $163 | 23 | 4 | $161 | 18 | N/A | $382 |
Steps to Improve Performance
- Track premium lens sales as a percentage of total lens sales.
- Break down the metric by insurance type to see how managed care patients respond to upgrade offers.
- Evaluate patient-staff conversations to ensure the focus is on savings and the benefits of premium lenses.
- Implement regular staff training to maintain consistency in messaging.
Regular analysis of this metric will provide insights into the success of your product positioning and communication strategies, helping you continually improve sales outcomes.
Expected Outcome
By implementing these strategies, practices can expect to see significant improvements in both profitability and patient satisfaction. The Average Patient Price for Lens Sales should increase as more patients opt for higher-value lenses. This will stem from staff effectively communicating the benefits of premium lenses, strategically framing insurance benefits as discounts, and presenting premium options as the preferred choice. When patients focus on how much they’re saving rather than what they’re spending, they feel more comfortable investing in higher-quality lenses.
Additionally, by reframing “zero dollar” lenses as a baseline option instead of the default choice, practices can minimize the impact of free lenses on overall sales. When staff lead with premium options and emphasize the benefits, patients are more likely to choose higher-value products that offer greater satisfaction and profitability.
Patients will also experience higher satisfaction when they fully understand their insurance benefits and feel empowered to make informed decisions. The emphasis on “savings” over “spending” helps them see their vision insurance as a valuable investment, making it easier to opt for premium lenses.
Ultimately, through careful tracking and management of the Average Patient Price for Lenses, practices will be able to fine-tune their sales strategy, ensuring that the optical department remains both profitable and patient-centric. Regular monitoring of premium lens upgrades will provide clear insights into how effectively your practice communicates value and positions its products.
Future-Proofing Your Practice
As the landscape of managed care continues to evolve, practices that consistently focus on offering premium lens options will be better positioned to succeed in the long term. By tracking key metrics like Average Patient Price, you can ensure your practice remains competitive and profitable, regardless of changes in managed care coverage.
Focusing on upselling premium lenses not only increases short-term profitability but also builds a loyal customer base that sees the value in quality eyewear. As patients grow more accustomed to the benefits of premium lenses, they are more likely to return for repeat purchases and refer others to your practice.
With this chapter on profitable lens sales complete, the next step in managing your practice effectively is turning to the performance of your staff. In the upcoming section, we will focus on using individual metrics to measure and improve individual contributions to the practice. By evaluating and managing performance on a personal level, you can drive staff engagement, improve customer service, and ensure your team is aligned with your business goals.
